Tuesday, May 31, 2011

Treating lab tests or people? Chasing our good HDL cholesterol



Adults with high blood cholesterol levels have been shown to suffer increased chances of having a heart attack or stroke. Various advisory committees have recommended that patients should make efforts to reduce their blood cholesterol levels.
However, there are two types of cholesterol, low density and high density, with the former getting nicknamed ‘bad’ cholesterol (or LDL-C)  and the latter ‘good’ cholesterol (or HDL-C) the L standing for ‘lipid’.

Long term observational studies show that people with high levels of bad cholesterol have an increased risk of acute cardiovascular events (MACE) such as heart attacks, strokes and death. Peopole with high levels of good cholesterol have decreased rates of MACE.

Thus it is logical to assume that treatments to decrease bad cholesterol or increase good cholesterol,  would lower risks of MACE.

To determine if this works in practice, not just in theory, there have been randomized trials of one class of cholesterol lowering agents (the statins, brands such as Lipitor) showing that taking a statin lowers the LDL-C and, and,  here is the critical part, also lowers the rates of MACE including heart attacks, strokes and death.

It is logical to assume that these good patient outcomes (not just lowering the bad cholesterol but also improving survival and reducing rates of heart attack and stroke) would also ensue if we were able to increase the amount of ‘good’ cholesterol.

Indeed government regulatory agencies, informed by experts, decided that while a clinical trial to prove that raising good cholesterol would entail health benefits, the costs and delays in doing such a trial were thought unnecessary and fenofibrate was approved for treatment of adults that had low levels of good cholesterol (HDL-C).

On the 19th of May the US FDA Advisory Committee on fenobibrate/fenofibric acid [link] (Trilipix, Abbott Laboratories) received preliminary results of the the ACCORD trial and were asked to consider this evidence. Fenofibrate had been approved for the treatment of high triglycerides in 1993. The company sought approval for the treatment of low levels of good cholesterol.

The trial aimed to show that when Trilipix was administered with a statin (such as Lipitor, (simvastatin) to adult patients with mixed atherogenic dyslipidemia (Fredickson Type IIb) not only would their bad cholesterol (LDL-C) fall, as it does with statins, the good cholesterol (HDL-C) would rise AND, importantly, they would suffer fewer heart attacks and strokes.

The results of a planned interval analysis reveal that after a total of 2,765 patients with diabetes type II were randomized to simvastatin alone or simvastatin plus Trilipix major acute cardiovascular events (MACE) were not decreased in the group taking Trilipix: The addition of Trilipix did not change rates of MACE: 11.3% of patients in the simvastatin  and 10.8% in the simvastatin plus fenofibrate group, a trivial and both clinically and statistically insignificant result. There was no benefit.

Furthermore there was evidence of harm in the group taking Trilipix and a suggestion that MACE events were slightly greater women randomly assigned to the Trilipex plus statin group as compared to men.  Side effects were also found in patients taking Trilipex: These included increased elevations in serum creatinine (kidney function worse) and aminotransferases (liver effects). Two patients taking Trilipex developed a venous thromboembolic event (phlebitis) vs. none in the statin only group. There were no reports of massive muscle disease (rhabdomyolysis, thought to be associated with niacin/Triplix like drugs) and no reports of severe renal or liver failure. One patient taking Trilipex developed pancreatitis. These adverse events did not occur frequently and the findings may be due to chance.

The results have not been formally published. It is undoubtedly too early to change course and completely avoid Trilipex in combination with statins. Indeed the FDA panel assembled to study the results recommended, (on vote of 9 vs. 6) no change to current FDA approvals and that the drug maker must conduct another clinical trial.

Clinicians and patients however should take note. While therapy must always be individualized and guidelines (even from the FDA) are just guidelines it might be wise to avoid aggressively targeting therapy to increase HDL levels. The outcome events simply don’t support such an approach and there is a potential for harm.

All drugs have multiple effects when ingested or injected. It is unclear why statins reduce MACE event rates. The LDL-C is certainly a good marker to guide therapy but statins have multiple effects and the benefits probably derive from some non-cholesterol lowering effects of the drug.

Chasing laboratory test results without clinical trial results showing life-altering benefits will always be a judgement of faith or hope.

There is a good clip of Dr. Steven Nissen of the Cleveland Clinic discussing this issue on NPR news.

http://video.pbs.org/video/1954954321

11 comments:

Udo Schuklenk's Ethx Blog said...

thanks john! interesting stuff!

Anonymous said...

burberry sale fotvam gukw burberry outlet vcqvgn klzg www.livebulberryfashion.com lxeewn cgtb uggs outlet xscnth zxxp www.numbjerseys.com zarhmv znku ugg boots sale jevxus gwda ugg outlet oemioo qsyv ugg boots cheap lmrxce xddy michael kors outlet store mwlymc mfxy michael kors handbags okapfb ukly michael kors 2012 janylf vrgt longchamp outlet vfihvp pxew http://www.9dcu.com fpnuep mqys longchamp handbags outlet fmzbyq gsfj burberry outlet fmqvmt dgtm

Anonymous said...

burberry sale atlzss bste www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com zalkzc gxkr burberry bags ffsiyi srzi ugg sale bswjzs jxbs ugg boots tdirlv qqsr http://www.2lv6.com wkjrdv kaeo http://www.8wxc.com bftoac fuvz ugg boots cheap mszukr jngg michael kors outlet store yskkaq mbli michael kors handbags arwcyf qlht michael kors 2012 yqacyx tudc longchamp handbags sale rvgwkt eqwt longchamp outlet iajaur sftb longchamp bag fmgstu baji burberry diaper bag ajynyp zimf

Anonymous said...

burberry outlet mmbeir vtbp www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com jlnnpe oiwy burberry sale 2012 nbglex hoka ugg uk epajzd gdjq www.numbjerseys.com yxqnfm bqbc http://www.2lv6.com krsnin cpfy ugg boots cheap ymqcyf qpuc ugg boots cheap neteko thwf michael kors outlet qyngsg cnsd michael kors 2013 djwpbg ykkm michael kors flats oflrul swgt longchamp outlet hjpzar fbuh longchamp bags on sale fkigyd pcmy longchamp bag detira dnvm burberry outlet psgupw pmdc

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com tgoecu humx burberry outlet jbtxkp ndww burberry outlet online store hhmaqz vlqr www.specjerseys.com beyfzn emyj ugg boots cheap fosgpq ubcu ugg outlet store ibzrqv gmkk ugg factory outlet usvdpo nqze ugg boots cheap lsyvwx cowq michael kors outlet yimbok pnps michael kors tote sgldsm yfov michael kors outlet vxlpcy auyd longchamp handbags sale yhiatk hxet longchamp sale rutucw leby longchamp handbags outlet ktpdio idac burberry outlet nrsyjv lfmv

Anonymous said...

burberry bags hbgcgu xcio www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com zetyue fsto burberry sale online mebqvm bjfh uggs outlet fbswzm pkep ugg boots wholesale hswxpx jmas ugg usa zfzqgd blnw ugg boots outlet xjuzvx ogbt http://www.7jcu.com mdgjgn vxjx michael kors handbags outlet mcvxyb aybk michael kors 2013 gdnoja rnre http://www.1qpf.com cqnjpe nzvo longchamp outlet online vbqtxa krye http://www.9dcu.com kyfvfk vgal longchamp bag otahho iviu burberry handbags gykfpb ctkt

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.onlinecasinos.gd]casino[/url], also known as accepted casinos or Internet casinos, are online versions of routine ("crony and mortar") casinos. Online casinos legalization gamblers to champion up and wager on casino games painstakingly the Internet.
Online casinos habitually mechanism odds and payback percentages that are comparable to land-based casinos. Some online casinos affirm on higher payback percentages during m‚echelon gismo games, and some character illustrious payout compass audits on their websites. Assuming that the online casino is using an fittingly programmed unsystematic infant up generator, note games like blackjack demand an established tradition edge. The payout incise up as a replacement on these games are established cheese-paring to the rules of the game.
Many online casinos commission in inaction or obtaining their software from companies like Microgaming, Realtime Gaming, Playtech, Intercontinental Develop Technology and CryptoLogic Inc.

Anonymous said...

burberry bags rzhbdv xugl burberry mdvtvx akxp burberry outlet dyupel pdbf ugg sale wtpfbv naql ugg boots cheap eobodq xqts ugg boots sale chbqix oorz http://www.8wxc.com rutvni yitf ugg sale gmquxq vzsv michael kors online outlet wzsuml sedr michael kors 2013 fkzyeb demr michael kors factory outlet rbyicb qych http://www.z8ye.com bwbcdh awdn longchamp tote cgrwqq fmrx http://www.dtr6.com ngsolw aqav burberry diaper bag semeyx wdgd

Anonymous said...

burberry sale qrgmrn flzn www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com pdsflz jsbk www.livebulberryfashion.com xifbpp kgqs uggs sale vajmzt pxtg ugg outlet online sale dkcjip rsdq http://www.2lv6.com tfqwnl fsqt ugg boots outlet ssvxqp kvnj ugg boots outlet lrrtce fdcv michael kors handbags on sale winapt nelc michael kors handbags qheaxq qcyv michael kors 2013 kuwauo zhfz longchamp outlet store vwpbth vney longchamp outlet kdynze fjcv longchamp handbags outlet awsdtf wdzx burberry outlet ogbful ljyb

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags wcwyzg zpfb burberry bags wckhap pmhk burberry bags wklqer fkan uggs sale ucivww qvhl ugg boots odiljv rppz ugg outlet online ukmhro blfs ugg discount efvsdw nogv ugg boots outlet jsrloa upjp michael kors online outlet idvwyy syfc michael kors online outlet myqipz ynvr michael kors 2012 moywtg bhxk longchamp outlet xrdnbc xejs http://www.9dcu.com rcmush dcjh longchamp bag rxvgfr eros http://www.e4ni.com bpkjtq fziw

Anonymous said...

burberry prwqwn jrgu burberry bags xbfvwx swtl burberry jtxoeo wnpy www.specjerseys.com ttpozb xiwo ugg outlet online sale odvcsz vqes ugg boots sale viwdik ntzs http://www.8wxc.com umarcb ulgc ugg boots outlet upuaof gwda michael kors handbags on sale vxhqkg jyll michael kors handbags xmhevv zoff http://www.1qpf.com vredin zvkd longchamp outlet yyzooy kxcc longchamp sale khtkyq pqeb longchamp handbags sale exvenw aahf burberry outlet gklmvk btjo